Seatrade-Maritime: Has the time come for ethanol as a maritime fuel?

Published by Seatrade-Maritime

Ethanol as a marine fuel is ready to be exported from the world’s largest producer in the US with a ready supply chain making a winner for both the producers and their potential marine clients.

That is the view expressed in GCGF’s latest report released today which notes that US ethanol production will reach 18.5 billion US gallons this year, the equivalent of around 55 million tonnes.

“Shipping’s fuel mix is expected to diversify as decarbonization regulations take effect. A key consideration for US stakeholders, including farmers, ethanol producers, ports and shipyards, is to what extent ethanol can take part in this transition,” said the report.

The US produces 51% of the world’s ethanol from more than 38.5 million hectares of corn crops more than 2 billion gallons of the fuel is shipped on an existing supply chain from farms by road, rail or barge to 200 biorefineries in 24 states and from there to the Gulf of Mexico ports at Houston and New Orleans as the major export terminals.

“Even at the most ambitious 2031 scenario, maritime ethanol demand would represent approximately 14% of projected U.S. corn production — a significant new demand channel, but one that is fully absorbable within the US agricultural system’s productive capacity,” according GCGF’s report.

Moreover, ethanol is liquid at ambient temperatures and can be handled in the same way as methanol, with the same regulations applying, but it has a higher calorific value than methanol.

However, ethanol can be corrosive to some materials and will require some modifications to some fuel components, including hoses, seals, gaskets, valve seats, and tank.

Moreover, it is clear that the output of ethanol will be insufficient to power the global fleet, it must, therefore, be considered as a drop-in fuel for existing vessels.

A number of trials of ethanol bunkering most notably by Maersk on some its methanol dual fuel ships. In October the Maersk Halifax took delivery of 5,000 tonnes of ISCC certified bioethanol in Singapore while at berth undergoing container handling operations. In late September the Maersk Halifax took a bioethanol bunker stem on board in the Port of Houston in late September.

Brazil uses ethanol extensively as a fuel in cars and the Port of Santos has now started offering ethanol bunkering.

In its report released last month on the use of ethanol as low carbon fuel the Mærsk Mc-Kinney Møller Center for Zero Carbon Shipping (MMMCZCS) said that there is an increasing interest from engine developers and ship owners and operators in ethanol as a drop-in fuel for engines designed for methanol operation.

Studies have shown that the systems designed for methanol, technical and regulatory are broadly similar.

“The remaining challenges for this ethanol use case relate mainly to optimisation, validation, and certification. Taken together, these reported findings paint a clear pathway for ethanol’s use in methanol-fuelled vessels,” noted the MMMCZCS report.

The challenge, however, is that most of the current fleet does is built for diesel, so the main pathway for the development of ethanol as a marine fuel will be as a drop-in fuel.

“Our laboratory tests showed that ethanol-MGO blends had a low flashpoint and a tendency to separate during longer-term storage. In addition, we identified the risk of blend separation when the fuel blend passes through the onboard fuel preparation system,” said the centre.

Another potential hazard with ethanol is its low flashpoint, around 13 degs C, well below that of IMO regulation for fuels with a flashpoint of not less than 60 degs C.

LNG has an ignition point far lower than the IMO regulation and is regulated through specialised safety frameworks.

The centre found reports of solutions to the separation and flashpoint challenges through additives, though the centre conceded: “We were unable to independently replicate the reported flashpoint-increasing effects of two fuel additives, our tests were not exhaustive� If increasing the flashpoint of ethanol-MGO blends ultimately proves infeasible, ships operating with ethanol must be equipped with dedicated safety systems.”

In order to over come these challenges the GCGF recommended that the US undertake six actions to kick-start the demand and supply of the fuel to the maritime sector.

In the first instance there must be a finalised marine life cycle assessment certification framework.

Such an assessment may have to include an assessment of the carbon emissions from corn production and the process of production of ethanol as a fuel, including corn delivery, milling, cooking, liquefaction, fermentation, distillation, dehydration through to storage and delivery.

Next US Coast Guard must develop regulations that govern domestic alcohol fuel use. That includes, number three the extension of the US Renewable Fuel Standard 2, to marine fuels, this would mandate a minimum volume of renewable fuel to blended with carbon fuels.

In addition, up to five pilot vessel programmes should be launched in US coastal waters to prove the concept.

Ethanol bunkering should be designated at up to five port hubs with state funding from Department of Transport, port grants and energy agency funding.

Lastly there is a need to build long-term offtake agreements: “Structured offtake between Midwest ethanol producers and marine bunkering operators; low-emission corridor commitments with cargo owners on priority routes.”

According to the GCGF the regulatory foundation for ethanol as a marine fuel is more complete than for any other low-emission fuel, other than methanol.

The IMO’s Net Zero Framework would create the economic conditions that will make ethanol a viable alternative.

That will depend largely on the what position Washington takes at the upcoming Net Zero discussions due to start later this month.

Related Posts