Seatrade-Maritime: Net Zero Framework discussions could be ‘existential’ for IMO
Published by Seatrade-Maritime
An observer at the International Maritime Organization (IMO) believes that the upcoming MEPC meetings at the regulatory body could prove existential if a significant vote against the Net Zero Framework (NZF) materialises.
The NZF will come up for a vote again at the 85th session of the Marine Environment Protection Committee (MEPC 85) with the resumption of the extraordinary session 2 (ES.2)
A 70-20 vote, where 20 member states oppose the NZF, could see the UN body break up the observer believes and ultimately lead to regional regulations where little if any of the carbon penalties collected are returned to the industry.
If the regulation is approved with a significant number of opposed member states the IMO “Could revert to being a technical body,” and nothing more than that said the source.
Or the US and other significant states could withdraw from the IMO, meaning it will “no longer be the IMO as we know it today and it could destroy the IMO,” added the source who attends IMO discussions.
Regional regulation will likely ensue: “The EU may be the best of the regulators, but it has just passed a rule where 50% of the carbon costs [from shipping] will be returned to the industry. But other regional regulators will not be as generous,” warned a senior industry figure.
Shipping as an industry, is not short of the cash to meet the proposed transition costs, however.
Speaking at last month’s Capital Link conference in London, former Clarksons director Martin Stopford calculated that shipowners had banked $3.1 trillion since 2020. More than enough to fund the $1.7 trillion up to 2050, calculated by UMAS to decarbonise the industry.
Yet, following last year’s failed Extraordinary Session (ES.2) of the MEPC, the regulation is still in the balance, not just because of cost to shipping, but also due to opposition from vested interests.
Much of the challenge for the MEPC is political and ideological as US delegates reportedly went from desk-to-desk last year threatening member states with economic sanctions if they voted for the NZF.
As we approach MEPC85 at the end of next month and the re-run of ES.2 in early December the industry is facing an impasse as petrostates, including Saudi Arabia, the UAE and major flag states including Liberia and Panama backed by US threaten to derail the process again.
It is a fact that the US has never liked the idea of the IMO becoming a fund manager, or ‘the fact that the UN body will raise ‘taxes’, which is how they regard carbon penalties.
The fund is critical for two reasons, first it will raise the cost of using fossil fuels, making alternative fuels more affordable, thereby assisting the transition.
And second, a large part of the funds would be used to assist small island developing states (SIDS) and least developed countries (LDCs) with decarbonisation and to mitigate against the effects of climate change, which they did not cause.
That was agreed as a key element of the NZF that would provide a Just and Equitable Transition for the LDCs and SIDS.
In order to square this circle member states have been making proposals that will bring the NZF opposition on board while also allowing for a meaningful regulation to be passed.
One proposal that has been touted by many observers was Japan’s paper submitted in August.
A paper that Tristan Smith, professor of energy and transport at University College London and a member of UCL’s Shipping and Oceans Research Group believes would be potentially “disastrous”.
Effectively the NZF fund would be replaced by a system of surplus units and direct payments to approved IMO approved projects.
Smith pointed out, with the system of direct payments, “The owner is allowed to choose where the money goes, they only have to report to the IMO that they have paid, that would kill the surplus unit market.”
According to NGO Opportunity Green (OG) this original submission was expanded on in a later submission to the Intersessional Working Group on GHG’s, but OG explains that the updated version does not materially change the effect of the proposal.
“This approach raises four interconnected concerns. Firstly, by removing the Net-Zero Fund and transferring greater control over the use of revenues to private actors.”
In effect Japan’s latest proposal gives no assurances that revenues will be provided for a just and equitable transition (JET).
Moreover, direct contributions by vessel owners “could result in larger fleet owners paying compliance revenues back into their own supply chains,” said OG.
Surplus units are supposed to reward GHG reduction, argue OG but the latest Japanese proposal undermines the connection between the two.
“By weakening the relationship between overcompliance, SU demand, and the value of surplus emissions reductions, the proposal risks creating a pay-to-pollute mechanism that undermines the NZF’s core objectives of reducing GHG emissions.”
In addition, the removal of the NZF Fund will remove the reward for operating on low emission fuels, thereby also removing an important source of funding for the development and deployment of low carbon fuels.
Most industry observers Seatrade Maritime News spoke to can see that a compromise deal on the greenhouse gas fuel intensity (GFI) is likely to be achieved, but the Net Zero Fund is seen as a challenge too far.
But while some industry observers believe that the GFI may be weakened, the feeling is that the GFI “Will be close to what we already have”.
Gavin Allwright, secretary general of the International Windship Association (IWSA) said: “We welcome all contributions to the discussion,” adding “All the elements passed must achieve the highest possible ambitions.”
The key impasse, as recognised by some member states who are looking for ways around the gridlock, is the Net Zero Fund.
As such the Japanese proposal to have a fund administered by a third party could provide what one senior industry source described as “an outline for a landing space for a compromise”.
According to Smith the idea that the IMO should manage individual disbursements from a massive fund worth billions of dollars was never plausible, “The IMO is not currently a competent organisation to operate such a fund,” he said.
It is more plausible that an institution such as the World Bank, International Finance Corporation or a multilateral development bank would be the more appropriate depository for the fund.
Smith, however, said it is unclear whether the US and other member states would accept such a solution.
Martin Crawford-Brunt, founder of consultancy Lookout Maritime, believes that there are few in favour of a Net Zero Fund, which means, “The SIDS and LDCs won’t be happy.”
He added that there is a problem with the global enforcement of any penalties “Given the geopolitical situation”.
According to the consultant “politicians are seeing dollars, but building a consensus will be challenging.”
“Shipowners, particularly in Greece, are saying that they are taxi drivers of the sea, they don’t produce fuel,” implying that the regulations are aimed at the wrong industry and should be directed upstream, added Crawford-Brunt.
That may be true and the regulators may see an opportunity to tax fuel producers too, that will help to fund the broader decarbonisation necessary to meet Paris targets. But those costs will likely be passed down the line to the consumer, along with increased shipping costs.
Related Posts
