Seatrade-Maritime: Reliability ‘unenforceable’ by shippers over ocean contracts
Published by Seatrade-Maritime
Container shipping reliability has been buffeted by multiple crises since 2020 and BCO’s (beneficial cargo owners) don’t see the situation improving with no way to penalise carriers for delays through contracts.
Schedule reliability for the top 13 largest container lines stood at 50.6% in September according to analyst Sea-Intelligence, ticking upwards 0.9 percentage points over the August after three straight months of decline. The most reliable line was Maersk with 64.8% schedule reliability while Wan Hai was the lowest coming in at just 26.7% reliability for September.
“I begin to think that ocean freight reliability will not improve much anymore. It’s going to be 50%, 55%, 60% at best,” said Jaya Moorthi, VP Logistics, International Ops (MEA, SAM, South Asia, Pacific & India) Schneider Electric, said at TOC Asia in Singapore.
He noted that over the last seven years since the beginning of the Covid pandemic there has been a crisis.
“Basically, what we are saying is, every year something will happen – there will be a reason why reliability gets bad. I haven’t seen a carrier who comes and sit downs and says, ‘I will seek to do better’,” Moorthi said.
“Ocean business is going to be a case where you book with a carrier and they will do their best for the price.”
There are no guarantees in terms of transit times and there is no way for the BCO to enforce reliability. “I haven’t seen a BCO that actually enforces it,” he stated.
“Ocean freight is becoming a very unenforceable contract over time.”
Vincent Chew, Consultant, Container Shipping Markets for Drewry Shipping Consultants, agreed and said, “performance would be hard to put into contracts at this point in time, reliability is low”.
“So, what we are advising our BCOs are that you have to concentrate on de-risking.”
With performance of lines unenforceable by BCOs Moorthi said it leaves them with an “enormous challenge”.
One method is if reliability is running at 50% but you want to get up to an equivalent of 70% BCOs have to bump up inventory levels in a country or region to provide a buffer to manage reliability, and there is a cost to that. “So, there is cost to this resilience, and this cost is going to pass onto the customer,” he stated.
In the case of port congestion that has been a big issue at major Chinese ports this year to the impact of severe weather multimodal can make a more efficient alternative to ocean shipping. By turning to multimodal Schneider Electric has in some cases has been able to cut a transit time of 60 days to 42 days. “We did quite a lot in 2026 to be honest.”
Related Posts
