Seatrade-Maritime: Sustainability challenge for ports and terminals – who will pay?
Published by Seatrade-Maritime
The strategy for ports and terminals decarbonise is clear with electrification the main route but justifying the investment and getting customers to pay is another matter.
Speaking on a panel on sustainability at TOC Asia, Ruben Emir Gnanalingam Bin Abdullah, Executive Chairman of Malaysian terminal operator Westports Holdings, said that the biggest issue with sustainability, not just in shipping but globally was that consumers are not ready to pay for it.
“The key question for me in sustainability is how do you how do you get more sustainable in a financially sustainable way? Because it has to also make sense financially, otherwise, you just you can’t just push on to try to be green when no one’s willing to pay for it,” he stated.
Vineet Mahajan, DP World’s Vice President & Head of Sustainability for Asia Pacific, agreed with Gnanalingam that ultimately responsibility to pay for decarbonisation lies with the cargo owner. “For us as the terminal operators, our clients are shipping lines, but ultimately, the end users, the cargo owners, and how willing they are to pay is what matters.”
Mahajan noted cargo owners were being pushed by their clients to go green and provide more visibility on emissions, so there is pressure on the cargo owners as well. However, he said, “Ultimately, there is some shift which has happened, but that is not good enough for us as the terminal operators to make huge investments in that side.”
When it comes to making investments in sustainability Gnanalingam said that in the case of Westports if a return on investment can be made, they will do it. For example, he said that around 16% of Westports energy now comes from their own solar farm in the port. “So, we produce our own energy that is 100% green.”
Westports has also invested in 60 electrified terminal tractors, however, electric vehicles in Malaysia are not necessarily greener than diesel as much of the country’s electricity is coal generated. “We did it because actually the cost is lower. It’s actually cheaper to go electric these days than to actually use diesel trucks,” he stated.
Fellow panelist, New Wei Siang Director, International Division for the Maritime and Port Authority of Singapore (MPA), noted that Singapore has a strategy to become net zero by 2050 and that the ports and terminal operator PSA were trying to electrify. “But even then, as was rightly mentioned earlier, it also depends on where what’s the source of your electricity.” In the case of Singapore about 95% of its electricity is generated from natural gas a fossil fuel.
In the case of DP World, which operates 16 ports and terminals across the Asia – Pacific region, it depends on the individual country if electrification makes sense in terms of reducing emissions. Mahajan noted that electrification made complete sense in Australia where renewable energy is readily available, and similarly in the Philippines. However, this not the case in for example Vietnam or Indonesia.
For its terminal operations in Indonesia DP World uses B40 biodiesel, which is 40% biofuel. “So there, if we change to grid electricity, our emissions will actually go higher. So that is the dilemma which we have in Indonesia,” he explained.
Gnanalingam said that if there is regulatory enforcement in the industry to decarbonise then making the choice to decarbonise becomes much easier as customers will have to pay. “For example, if say shore power becomes a global necessity everywhere, then of course we will then have to charge for it to shipping lines.”
Related Posts
