Shippingtelegraph: Fifteen shipping companies raise concerns over IMO’s Net-Zero Framework
Published by shippingtelegraph
Fifteen member companies of the Getting to Zero Coalition, the majority of which are shipowners in the container, dry bulk, and tanker sectors, had been consulted about how proposed alternatives to the IMO’s Net-Zero Framework would impact their decision-making. Charterers, fuel producers, and infrastructure-side industry members were also consulted.
The findings from the consultations with the 15 companies raise concerns as the message received has been clear: enforcement of compliance should involve a real penalty, and the alternatives proposed would create risks and burdens for the industry without solving any substantive problems.
The companies consulted were mostly based in Europe and Asia, with some participation from Latin American and US-based companies, but collective operational coverage from the 15 members is global.
In the run-up to the 23rd Intersessional Working Group (ISWG 23) and 85th Marine Environment Protection Committee (MEPC 85), member states of the International Maritime Organization (IMO) have been meeting informally to find a potential pathway for agreeing and adopting a robust set of policy measures capable of delivering on the IMO’s 2023 Greenhouse Gas (GHG) Strategy.
Those informal meetings have led to several new design ideas about how companies could be required to comply with regulation.
The Global Maritime Forum’s Getting to Zero Coalition has engaged with its member companies to better understand how business cases for decarbonisation, including zero- and near-zero fuels, would be impacted by the alternative designs being discussed.
Of particular focus have been the enforcement mechanisms that could serve as alternatives to the penalties (remedial units) envisioned in the Net-Zero Framework.
These alternatives, direct contributions or voluntary units, have been put forward as attempts to find agreement around the economic element, and the contested idea of establishing a fund or facility to manage the collected fees.
To remind, the first mechanism, the remedial unit, featured in the Net-Zero Framework (NZF) agreed at MEPC 83. The other two mechanisms, direct contributions and voluntary units, are more recent proposals. These new proposals are framed, according to Global Maritime Forum’s Getting to Zero Coalition, as seeking political common ground, particularly around the economic element and the management of associated funds.
In the three questions, if they will help shipowners comply more efficiently or if they would result in lower trade costs or if they would promote investment in zero- and near-zero -emission fuels, the answer from the 15 companies consulted so far has been a clear “no” on all fronts.
These companies also worried that the new alternatives would increase complexity, distort the market, and create reputational risks for the industry, all without enabling delivery of the IMO’s 2023 GHG Strategy.
Currently, discussions are ongoing and the detail of any eventual proposal would need to be ironed out either in the legal text or in guidelines for implementation.
The next meeting of the Intersessional Working Group on Reduction of Greenhouse Gas (GHG) Emissions from Ships (ISWG-GHG 23) is scheduled for 23 to 27 November, ahead of MEPC 85 from November 30 to December 3.
The second extraordinary session of MEPC that was adjourned last October is scheduled to resume on December 4, subject to discussions at MEPC 85.
Related Posts
