Splash247: Why shipowners might be better off sharing profits than taking on debt
Published by Splash247
Traditional loans demand repayments regardless of freight markets. Earnings-sharing structures offer a different proposition: investors participate in a vessel’s fortunes while owners retain control. Captain Vikas Pandey from Shipfinex explains.
Ship finance looks healthy on paper. Petrofin Research estimates that the top 40 shipping banks grew their portfolios by 6% in 2025 to $300.6bn, and puts total ship finance across banks, leasing, export credit and alternative lenders at around $680bn. Societe Generale expects 2026 to remain a borrower’s market, with top-tier owners seeing margins of 100 to 150 basis points over SOFR.
That is accurate for owners at the top. It is less accurate for the rest. Petrofin’s index of global bank ship finance stands at 63 against 100 in 2008, while the value of the fleet and orderbook has risen to about $2.17trn. Small and mid-sized owners, who by one industry estimate own up to 60% of the world’s ships, still meet low advance ratios on older tonnage, higher margins, or alternative lenders asking for equity kickers and profit participation on top of interest.
For these owners, a third structure is worth understanding: selling a share of a single vessel’s future net earnings to outside investors, while the owner keeps title, management and commercial control.
Cost. Where an owner can borrow at today’s bank margins, debt is almost always cheaper. Investors taking freight-market risk expect returns closer to equity. The comparison changes when the realistic alternative is private credit priced well above bank debt, with fees, tighter covenants and a profit share attached. At that point the owner is already paying for equity risk while still carrying the rigidity of a loan.
Cash flow. This is the bigger difference. Debt service is fixed. Amortisation often runs shorter than the vessel’s remaining economic life, a balloon creates refinancing risk at maturity, and a minimum value clause can force prepayment or extra security when asset values fall. None of this adjusts when the charter market softens. An earnings share does. Investors receive an agreed percentage of net operating cash flow, so distributions fall when rates fall, and a weak quarter is not a default event. For an owner whose main exposure is a liquidity squeeze in a downturn, rather than the headline cost of capital, that flexibility has real value.
Control. Investors in an earnings-share structure hold an economic right, not title. The vessel typically sits in a single-ship SPV that remains the registered owner, and the owner keeps technical and commercial management, crewing and chartering. Investors receive regular reporting and a vote on a short list of reserved matters, such as a sale of the vessel, new borrowing or a change of manager. A lender’s covenants, by contrast, can restrict distributions, require consent for employment and accelerate the loan on breach. Both structures constrain the owner, in different places.
When it fits. Earnings-sharing tends to make sense where bank debt is unavailable or priced close to equity; where the vessel has visible employment, such as a period charter, that investors can underwrite; where the owner needs to protect liquidity through the cycle; or where equity is locked in an unencumbered vessel that the owner wants to release without selling. For an owner with cheap bank finance and a firm view that rates will rise, it gives away upside.
Before signing, owners should settle the definition of net earnings and deductible costs, the treatment of off-hire and drydocking, reserve funding, the term and any cap on investor returns, buy-back rights, and what happens on a sale or total loss. Where a first-priority registered ship mortgage is in place, the mortgagee’s consent is required and investor distributions rank behind debt service.
Debt remains the cheapest capital in shipping for owners who can get it on good terms. For many who cannot, sharing earnings matches the cost of capital to the way a ship actually earns its money.
Related Posts
